First,
as the story was first presented in Flash
Comics #1 Vol. 1,
we had prince Khufu Kha-Tarr and princess Chay-Ara, the two noble
figures of royalty who were best known for their being anti-slavery,
and who had to fight to put a stop to the evil kingdom that Hath-Set,
who became their leading arch-nemesis, came from. But while they
managed to defeat said kingdom of the times, they were sadly slain by
the cursed dagger used by Hath-Set, which he forged from Ninth Metal,
when he snuck up on them in a temple in those ancient times, before
being put to death himself by the rest of Khufu's army. (See also Secret Origins #11, where the story
was retold.)
Thus began the cycle of reincarnation of these three individuals in
many eras to follow.
Ancient
Israelite period(?)(circa 1000 B.C)
I'm sure Hawkman was kidding when he
said this, but in Flash #191 Vol. 2,
he said that
he'd once fought a giant on a mountaintop! Meaning, in other words,
that he was making it sounds as if he'd been King David in a past
incarnation, and Hath-Set could very well have been the Philistine
army general Goliath?
Either way, Flash was pretty
surprised and flattered when he heard
this, as Hawkman headed back to Saint Roch following their battle with
Brother Grimm, and so was I. (And then of course, I was charmed and
amused by how Linda Park West told Wally West that he was "so cute when he's confused.") And
while it's not something you can confirm so easily, I wouldn't be
surprised if Carter had been incarnated in the ancient Israelite
period, though in a simpler life, but not as a real life figure like
David.
Roman
Empire period (100 A.D)
There is the possibility that Hawkman for one was reincarnated as a
Roman legionnaire in the time of the Roman empire. And that he may have
been slain by Hath-Set, who may have in turn been reincarnated as a
soldier from a rival army. This possibility was suggested in the 26th
issue of volume four.
Speaking of which, Hawkman # 25
volume
3 featured a
gladiator named Abrihim Barabbas, who was transformed into an angelic
winged warrior known as Gabriel. He died while fighting a demonic
lion-man, which could very well have been a precursor to Lion-Mane, the
crook who first appeared in Hawkman
#20 vol. 1 in 1967.
Ancient
medival England period (500 A.D)
In this era, a stable boy named Brian Kent, with the help of a falcon
named Slasher, takes up the guise of the Silent Knight to battle the
tyranny of his uncle, the sinister Sir Oswald, and to defend the honor
of Lady Celia Penbrook. The story was originally featured in The Brave and the Bold #1-22, and
was later updated in Secret Origins
#49.
Medival
England period, 11th-12th century (1079-1142)
In Hawkman #29 Volume 4, it's
strongly hinted that Peter Abalard, a novelist, was a past life of
Carter's. In this issue, Carter was showing Domina a love letter
Abalard wrote his beloved Heloise.
Medival
France, 14th century
In a conversation with Hawkwoman Shayera Thal, in volume 4's 16th
issue, Carter mentions that he was an archer in ancient France, “some six hundred years ago.”
15th
century period (1452-1483)
In this era, Carter
lived a life as a bishop in medival England, as was told in Hawkman #26 Volume 4. He knew a
soldier in that time named Thomas whom he thought had died in a battle,
but who was reborn in the 20th century as a vampire named Gray, and who
then tried to attack Hawkgirl and turn her into a vampire as well.
Luckily, Hawkman was able to trap him in an office complex, where he
used some blessed holy water to destroy both Gray and his gang of other
vampires, and to heal Hawkgirl of any influence the vampire's attack
caused.
(It's possible that even beforehand, Carter had been incarnated as an
English
knight himself, and the Stonechat Museum contains at least one suit of
armor that suggests that.)
15th-16th
century period (1483-1514, and 1535-1580)
Possibly a protagonist named Koenraad Von Grimm for starters, then he
was reincarnated as a personal bodyguard of Sonam Gyatso, the Third
Dalai Lama, who lived from 1543-1588. (Hawkman
#37 Vol. 4) Carter said he spent “several decades” as Gyasto’s
personal guard, though because his next life, as John Smith (the
explorer from England who met the Indian tribe of Pocahontas), was born
in the year that this previous life ended, it's not entirely clear.
16th-17th
century period (1580-1631)
In Hawkman #18 Vol. 4, it's
suggested that Carter may have been reborn as the British explorer John
Smith, who met the Indian tribe of Pocahontas in his time. I'm sure
this was just a suggestion though.
17th
century period (1632)
An alleged sorcerer known as the Purple Pilgrim is sentenced to death
by Judge Sanders. The Pilgrim responds by cursing him "and all who may come after you and bear
your hated name." Viewing the man's punishment as unjust, a
faction of the community decides "to cut themselves off from the
colonies" and move to a completely isolated area known as Hidden Valley.
Later on, a would-be thief discovers Hidden Valley and the legend of
the Purple Pilgrim. Claiming to be a descendant of the 17th Century
villain, the new Purple Pilgrim appears to renew the old feud with the
Sanders family when he murders four members of the clan. Choosing his
targets on the basis of their wealth, the Pilgrim also loots their
properties in the course of the attacks. After Shiera is attacked and
kidnapped, Carter trails her to the Purple Pilgrim's safe house in
Hidden Valley to rescue her, and convinces the reclusive community that
they have been duped. This story was first told back in Flash Comics #86 Volume 1.
18th-19th
century period
A flashback panel in the 4th issue of volume 4 indicates that
Carter may have once been reincarnated as a black slave, at the time
slavery was being legalized in the old US. Some later issues also
featured this too, with Shiera also seen in a previous incarnation
as a black slave, and together they fled from a plantation ruled by
Hath-Set's incarnation of the time.
19th
century western period (1865-1892)
Issue #7 of volume 4
revisions
the old DC western hero Nighthawk, first seen in Western Comics #5 in October 1948,
as having been Carter back in those times, and Sheira as having been
the female gunfighter named Cinnamon, first seen in Weird Western Tales #48 in
September/October 1978. The two of them would meet cute in St. Roch
(time setting being around 1898, to say the least) and
pair up for many other adventures, the first one being to help out
Cyrus Evans, the ancestor of Oliver Evans, who was falsely charged with
slaying his boss, the owner of the estate that would in time become the
Stonechat Museum in St. Roch. (Issue #18 also contains some more of
that story.)
Not only that, it even indicates that Nighthawk once met the bounty
hunter Jonah Hex during his adventures in the old west. As for
Hath-Set, it would seem as if he'd been reincarnated, most eerily
enough, as Matilda Dunney, the real culprit responsible for the death
of Evans' boss, unless what Dunney actually was was an ancestor of
Helene Astar, one of Hath-Set's own descendants who'd tried to menace
Infinity Inc. during the 1980's.
Special
section:
Western Incarnation Profiles
Late
19th-early 20th
century period (1892-1917)
Carter lived a brief life as a detective named Jimmy
Wright, and Shiera as a femme fatale named Sheila Carr, as told in Hawkman #27 Vol. 4. Wright tripped
to St. Roch to investigate a case involving a local crime boss at the
time named Big Louie Moretti, one of Hath-Set's incarnations from then,
and ran into Carr, an old flame of his, who was serving as a moll for
Big Louie's mob. When he finally traced Big Louie, he found that the
gangster had engineered their meeting, claiming a past hatred of both
Jimmy and Sheila. Helping Sheila escape, Jimmy suddenly realised who
she was - the woman he has loved through all his many lives - and they
were united for a few seconds before being gunned down by Moretti, who
was none other than an incarnation of their old enemy, Hath-Set.
An interesting aside, there is a supporting character here called Sam,
a friend of Wright's, who may be intended to be Samuel Dashiell Hammet,
the famous mystery novelist who wrote the classic Thin Man and the Maltese Falcon. The writer of this
issue, of course, is Ed Brubaker, who began as a mystery/suspense
novelist himself, and no doubt wrote this issue as a tribute to the
works of Hammett.
20th
century period (1920 and onwards)
The prince is reincarnated as Carter Hall, historian and artifact
collector, and it was here that, after coming upon a Ninth Metal dagger
in his collection and his exposure to its magical effects, that his
memory for starters was restored, and eventually, his princess,
reincarnated as Sheira Saunders, was restored too. So too in fact was
Hath-Set's after a run-in with Carter, after which he tried to menace
the two lovers, but luckily, they defeated him.
The rest, as they say, is now history.
Extra notes: Possibility of
being a Japanese Samurai, either in the 13th or 19th centuries, seen in
Hawkman #18 Vol. 4; Spanish
swordsman, seen in Hawkman #9 Vol. 4;
Aztec Warrior Priest, though it could also be another South American
culture that isn't Aztec; Chinese Soldier; man from Tibet, all seen in Hawkman #12 Vol. 4. You could even
include a scene from Hawkman #18
Vol. 4 that seemed to show Carter incarnated as a small bird, of
all things, and Hath-Set as a vicious owl. Whenever that takes place
isn't clear though.
"The
past and present must work
together, not independently. One learns from the other -- rejecting the
bad, accepting the good." --
Hawkman, Flash Comics #67 Volume 1.
(Special thanks to David Endicott for
providing some extra info/details for this section.)